Review daga cikin littafin "Bone ya tabbata daga wit". "Bone ya tabbata daga wit" Griboyedov: reviews

A play Griboyedov "Bone ya tabbata daga wit" da aka rubuta dogon da suka wuce, amma munasaba ne har yanzu ba rasa cewa, a gaskiya, a fairly rare abu, musamman ga siyasar satire. Yawancin wadannan littattafai su ne dace kawai, har irin wannan lokaci kamar yadda a can aka soki yanayin. Wannan shi ne bayyanannu a cikin mafi mashahuri a lokacin kaifi, mai kaifin, caustic ayyukan shahararren Soviet adawa. Ya shi da kyau, ka littattafai? Hakika, a. Shin, sunã sha'awar yanzu, bayan rushewar tarayyar Soviet? No. More - ba.

munasaba m

Don siyasa satire ya ba kama baki-da-fari m da wani dogon-manta iyali, shi dole ya zama wani abu mafi, ba kawai unsophisticated nan da nan nuni da shortcomings al'umma. Nassoshi mutum matsaloli da kuma dabi'u, gane, masõyansa a kowane lokaci da kuma ga kowa da kowa.

Kuma Griboyedov, samar da wãsa, ya sa a cikin shi sosai fiye da kawai wani sharhi na gudanar da harkokin siyasa da kuma tsarin zamantakewa. Yana kiwon kusan duk wani, dauka a bazuwar, review, samfurin, "Bone ya tabbata daga wit" bisa ga a kalla a cikin wucewa. M hoto na hali - kuma ba kawai ga lokaci na Alexander I. Wadannan guda mutane suna zaune a yanzu. Eh, suna sanye daban, hayaki taba sigari, ba snuff, tattauna da latest Putin ta magana a taron, kuma ba sarki kafin daraja taro. Amma maza ne guda. Babu shakka recognizable iri.

haruffa comedy

Careerists da conformist. M jarumi campaigner. M tradesman da gaskiya akida views. Tsohon maza - da guda na baya. Sister, damu kawai nasu matrimonial tsare-tsaren. Romantic yarinya wakiltar your rayuwa ne kawai daga littattafai. A karshe, babban harafin - mai harshen wuta masu sassaucin ra'ayi da kuma jirgin saman soja. Kowa zai iya Lalle ne anã daya ko biyu da suka abokai, a full yarda da wadannan fassarorin. Babu review na littafin "Bone ya tabbata daga wit" ba ba tare da bincike na da recognizable hali daban, ko shi da aka rubuta a cikin karni na 19th ko 21st. Just dangantakar dake tsakanin irin mutane daban-daban, da kuma} ir} m rikici misoneism, liberalism kuma conservatism ne daya daga cikin biyu sandunansu ma'ana daga cikin play.

zargi Goncharova

Shekaru biyu da suka rubuta Griboyedov "Bone ya tabbata daga wit". Bitar Goncharova IA - daya daga cikin mafi kyau sukar da ya lokaci - ya dauki wannan aikin da Masterpieces na Rasha wallafe-wallafe. Its review da zuwa wannan rana shi ne daya daga cikin mafi kyau da ƙididdiga daga cikin play. Wannan shi ne - a cika, cikakken, bincike na yadda da mãkirci aiki, da haruffa, mai kwatanta da sauran zamani marubuta Griboyedov. Wannan m labarin da aka rubuta kusan shekaru 50 bayan da bazawa na comedy. Domin adabi, ko da shekaru 50 - shi ne lokaci mai tsawo, biyu zamaninsu. A wannan lokaci da samfurin ko aka rabu amfani - ko zama classic.

Sam Goncharov lura da cewa images of lyric heroes of Pushkin, kuma Lermontov - Onegin da Pecherin mamaye wani wuri a cikin wallafe-wallafen matsayi ne incomparably mafi girma a kwatanta da Griboyedov - ba ma ban sha'awa ga jama'a. Su unrecognizable. Wannan irin ne tafi, tare da lokacin da suka haifi. Tunaninsu, su ji, su matsaloli da kuma fatan an tafi, tare da m 18th karni.

Hoton na da babban harafin

Chatsky har yanzu recognizable - biyu a girma da kuma a shortcomings. Shi ne da hukunci, sau da yawa m, kuma m. Watakila ma ma m - da yawa daga cikin jawabin da aka ba ko zama m, kuma frankly m, da kuma abin da ya an soki Sofia. Duk da haka, idan ka tuna game da shekaru (Chatsky bayan kusan ashirin), shi ne quite sa ran da na halitta. Matasa maximalism peculiar keta. Da magana gnomic - sun fi mayar saboda bayar da play wani rabo. Quotes na monologues Chatsky je ya zuwa yanzu, mutane sau da yawa ba su ma san cewa fi so karin magana - wani layi na comedy Griboyedov.

Rare review na littafin "Bone ya tabbata daga wit" dispenses tare da jawabinsa a Chatsky hankali da kuma son zuciyarsa ga canji. Da yawa kasa kula da ma'ana cewa ya yayi Magana da yawa amma ya aikata kome ba.

Chatsky da liberalism

Wannan batu ne ko ta yaya tsere hankalin mafi sukar. Ba su danganta wa] annan ayyana Chatsky theses tare da hanyarsa ta rayuwa. Ya yi imanin serfdom girma relic na baya - amma zare jiki na zaune a kudi na serfs. Girman kai ba zai yale shi ya kowtow da iko da ya zama - amma Chatsky akwai zare jiki domin kudi, ba sanã'anta su. Ya tsauta wa a kusa da soldafonstve Skalozub - amma kaucewa watsi da gaskiyar cewa wannan soja jami'in da ke yaki da wannan lambar yabo-lashe, da kuma ba "parquet soja."

Liberal Chatsky aiki ta fara da ƙare voluminous monologues, magana kafin jama'a, wanda lalle ba ya shawo.

A comedy kira "Bone ya tabbata daga wit". Ma'anar sunan ne quite m. Amma a nan a kan dutsen nan Chatsky hankali? Kamar yadda, duk da haka, da yawa daga cikin masu sassaucin ra'ayi hanya na Rasha, wanda shi ne don haka a tune da yanayi na protagonist. Idan ka yi tunani game da shi - shi dai itace cewa da shi ne ba a wuce haddi na tunani, da kuma rashin iyawa ga amfani da shi.

Masu sukar da kuma haruffa

Mene ne wani sharhi? Wannan shi ne kawai daki-daki, mai karatu muhawwara ra'ayi game da samfurin. Duk da haka, da sukar lamiri - shi ne ba kawai mai karatu, a matsayin sana'a, ta shirya da karatu, amma har yanzu. Kuma kamar yadda na gaskiya, ya ce La Bruyere, da littafin ne kamar madubi. Idan shi ya dubi biri, ba za ka iya sa ran cewa, gani zai nuna da Manzo. Wannan shi ne, duk wani sharhi - da farko a gani da mai karatu ta duniya, ba marubuci. Kuma wani nazari na littafin "Bone ya tabbata daga wit" - mai daukan hankali tabbatarwa. Writers da wuya mutane ayyuka. Domin su zuwa ce - wannan shi ne wani aiki. Wata kila wannan shi ne dalilin da ya sa irin wannan kauce hilafa tsakanin ayyana nufi da ainihin hali tsere su da hankali.

prototypes Chatsky

A wannan batun, quite nuni da play kanta ne abun da ke ciki - shi bai kubuta hankalin wani daya review na littafin "Bone ya tabbata daga wit". The aiki ne zuwa kashi biyu daidai storylines. Farko - soyayya, dangantaka da kuma Chatsky Sophia, ta kasance a cikin wani wasa da babban. Amma ba a nan. A wannan wasa romantic layi - kamar wani labarin engine, zane, zane. Wani aiki, kowane yi na haruffa - kawai uzuri ga wani monologue Chatsky. Ya gaske unusually talkative. The adadin rubutu cewa da dama a kan Chatsky, sau da yawa ƙara na replica na wani hali. Ya yayi Magana da wasu haruffa, tare da kansa, tare da masu sauraro. Da alama cewa haruffa daga cikin play da kuma je a kan mataki zuwa Chatsky iya ba su da wani dogon kimantawa. A gaskiya, shi ne wannan alama ya ba Yunƙurin zuwa zargin da babban harafin da marubucin canza son kai - a irin ƙaho, da yiwuwar karfi, daga mataki ya bayyana nasu matsayi, amma wasu mutane ta bakinsu. Sau da yawa daga cikin yiwu samfur na hali kira fi na fasaha, talented Chaadaeva. Ga kuma m kama sunan kuma suna da wani mahaukaci. Wata ila ya yi da gaske aiki a matsayin wani samfur na protagonist daga cikin play "Bone ya tabbata daga wit". Ma'anar sunan a cikin wannan yanayin ne bayyananne - lalle ne, haƙĩƙa, Chaadaev aka san zurfin philosophic sito hankali da kome amma matsaloli, shi ne don ba wadãtar.

An sabon abu look at Chatsky

Ko da yake akwai daidai gaban ka'idar, albeit ba yaduwa. A yawan wallafe-wallafen sukar yi imani da cewa satire Griboyedov sirara kuma zurfi. Its batu - ba kawai m FAMUSOV, Molchalin REPETILOV da Skalozub, amma ya Chatsky. Mai yiwuwa ne wanda ba a iya lura da shi ba talkativeness lokacin da cikakken rashin aiki - kawai wani wargi da marubucin. Kuma siffar babban harafin - a parody image-m talker, m na mataki, kuma ba ya so shi.

Hakika, yana da matukar m kamannuna a bango na wannan irin review. Comedy "Bone ya tabbata daga wit" ya dade da aka wajabta misali, da kullum yarda da fassarar. Yana kafa daga cikin darussan da na adabi, shi za a iya karanta a wani littafi. Amma wani m tsarin kula da nazari da samfurin kuma yana da hakkin ya wanzu. Ko da yake har yanzu wasa zane da ke sa wannan zato ne mai wuya. Idan wani parody na m - ya Chatsky, me ya sa ta shiga cikin labarin Repetilov? Sai suka dauki wannan ma'ana alkuki. Iyakar abin da bambanci shi ne cewa Chatsky kaifin baki da kuma REPETILOV frankly wawa.